3.6 Impacts of Future Growth

Water Quantity and Quality

Land use change impacts downstream water quality by increasing the volume of runoff and the concentration and load of nutrients and sediment transported to receiving waters.  Table 9 illustrates how land use change such as the expected conversion of agricultural and vacant land to low-density residential could be expected to impact water quality in Dutch Lake.  The table also illustrates the impact of a regulatory program managing these impacts.

?Ultimate development? is defined as the conversion of all agricultural lands and one-half of the upland forested area that remains undeveloped in the 2020 local government land use plans.   This conversion may take place by 2030 or require significantly more time, but it is assumed that at some point in the future these conversions will occur.  More detail regarding this modeling can be found in Technical Appendix A.

Table 9 contrasts three loading reduction scenarios.  Scenarios 1 and 2 contrast the required load reductions if there were no regulatory program to the requirements under the existing regulatory program.  The HHPLS assumed that there would be no load increase from future development; the third scenario in Table 9 indicates that even with a stringent regulatory program that strictly prohibits any new phosphorus loading, additional reductions would be necessary to achieve the desired phosphorus concentration goal of 40 ?g/L.

Table 9.  Dutch Lake modeled 2020 and ultimate development water quality and the total phosphorus loading reduction necessary to achieve its in-lake total phosphorus concentration goal of 40 ?g/L.

Dutch Lake Goal = 40 ?g/L



Ultimate Development

Scenario 1:  No Regulatory Program

Predicted in-lake TP (?g/L)



P load decrease needed to achieve 40 ?g/L (lbs/year)



Scenario 2: Current Regulatory Program

Predicted in-lake TP (?g/L)




P load decrease needed to achieve 40 ?g/L (lbs/year)



Scenario 3: Regulatory Program That Prohibits A Net Increase in Loading from New Development

 (As assumed in HHPLS) 

Predicted in-lake TP (?g/L)



Additional P load decrease needed to achieve 40 ?g/L (lbs/year)



Other Impacts

The Dutch Lake subwatershed ecosystem faces varying threats from degradation as a result of development pressure, urbanization, and subsequent channelization of stream conveyances that go beyond impacts to water quality and hydrology.   Development can directly or indirectly degrade and fragment habitat, and reduce or eliminate the opportunities for natural stormwater management provided by minimally disturbed grasslands, forests, woodlands, and wetlands.

The establishment of the connectivity between ecosystems will become increasingly difficult as development encroaches on the corridor.  Currently about one-fourth of the subwatershed is urbanized.  It is expected that about one-third the existing agricultural and half of the forested lands will be converted to low-density residential development by 2020.  These conversions to large-lot development would likely create a patchwork of remnant woodland, grassland, and wetland.  Many species require significant contiguous areas of habitat in which to hunt or brood.  The fragmentation that would result from development would limit the ecological integrity of the entire area.